November 16, 2026
Blog

Investigative belief does not automatically translate into safe evidence

Dr Matt Tart discusses the importance of opinion, expertise and accreditation in cell site evidence

When can the right expert make the difference?

The value of the right expert is rarely confined to writing a report. It may arise during initial assessment, disclosure review, conference with counsel, expert discussions, aiding cross-examination or appeal. The earlier issues are identified, the greater the opportunity to influence the direction of the case. But what issues might there be?

  1. Stated Opinion: Why should I care?
    1. The location of the phone is not contained within the call data. Cell Site Analysis requires inference. Inference is opinion.
      1. There is nuance in the data considered. It is accepted that the jury cannot be expected to safely understand this nuance. In R v Calland (2018) the prosecution had “unhelpfully conflated the location of a particular mast with the question of what safe inferences can be drawn about the telephone using it”. Furthermore “The jury were in danger of being drawn into making a speculative assumption for which there was no evidential foundation”.
      2. An expert is therefore required.
      3. The role of the expert is not to lead the jury to a specific conclusion; they should not be acting as advocates. They should provide neutral assistance to the court by helping to ensure that the jury are not left drawing conclusions from technical evidence without a proper evidential foundation.
    2. Sound inference requires structure.
      1. That structure is defined in the FSR Code. Requirements are designed to ensure that evidence is impartial, robust, logical, balanced and transparent.
      2. Absence of this structure can lead to unsafe evidence.
      3. Opinion should be capable of scrutiny by all parties.
  2. Demonstrable Expertise: Why should I care?
    1. Who is actually interpreting the evidence?
      1. Investigative belief does not automatically translate into sound evidence.
      2. Creating technical findings and evaluating them are different processes.
      3. Opinion must be provided by a competent expert, just as for any other Forensic Science Activity. The competencies required to do this are beyond those required for generating maps and tables from call data.
    2. Unsafe inference has contributed to miscarriages of justice.
      1. The issue of unsafe inference is not unique to cell site analysis. Courts have encountered problems in other forensic disciplines where the technical findings were sound, but the conclusions drawn from them were not. In R v Preece, the findings were in the field of biology. In R v Ward, explosives.
      2. In each case, the technical findings themselves were not the central problem. The difficulty arose when conclusions were drawn that extended beyond what the findings could properly support
      3. These shortcomings were exposed in appeal, many years after the problems occurred.
  3. Accreditation: Why should I care?
    1. Can I trust the process?
      1. The FSR Code is designed to reduce the risk that forensic science activities might mislead. The FSR Code is statutory; compliance is not voluntary.
      2. Compliance is binary. Either the provider can demonstrate compliance through validated methods, competent personnel and quality assurance, or they cannot. If compliance cannot be demonstrated, there are obvious questions regarding reliability, weight and admissibility.
      3. Accreditation provides independent assurance that the expert's competence, methods and quality systems have been assessed rather than simply asserted. Absence of accreditation requires a leap of faith; just because a provider has been doing it for a long time does not mean that they have been doing it safely.
    2. Can I challenge the evidence?
      1. If the evidence becomes important, can it withstand scrutiny? Anyone can produce a map or table, but maps and tables rarely answer the question the court is actually trying to resolve. The issue is what those observations mean in the context of the competing positions taken by the Prosecution and Defence. The value of the expert lies in explaining what conclusions can safely be drawn from the data and where the limits of the evidence lie.
      2. Failures in validation, competence, inference or quality systems can become issues in disclosure, admissibility and perceived probative value. Robust process protects both prosecution and defence.
      3. There are established mechanisms to challenge evidence before it reaches the jury, including under s.78 PACE, the Criminal Procedure Rules and the Criminal Practice Directions.

In conclusion

The earlier evidential weaknesses are identified, the greater the opportunity to address them before they become issues at trial or appeal. A competent expert, operating from within an accredited environment can assist by:

  1. Early case assessment: identifying evidential strengths and weaknesses
  2. Case preparation: testing prosecution assumptions and processes
  3. Joint expert discussions and conferences
  4. Trial: clearly explaining limitations and responding robustly to challenge
  5. Appeal: identifying flaws in interpretation, methodology or process which may not have been recognised originally

For more information on any aspect of the above, please contact:

Dr Matt Tart
matthew.tart@cclsolutionsgroup.com

‍

‍

We're here to help

Our experts are on hand to learn about your organisation and suggest the best approach to meet your needs. Contact an expert today.

Get in touch
hexes